© Reuters.
Explore Wall Street’s expert insights with this ProResearch article, which will exclusively be available to InvestingPro subscribers soon. Enhance your investment strategy with ProPicks, our newest product featuring strategies that have outperformed the S&P 500 by up to 700%. This Cyber Monday, enjoy up to 60% off, plus an extra 10% off a 2-year subscription with the code research23, reserved for the first 500 quick subscribers. To ensure ongoing access to valuable content like this, step up your investment game with InvestingPro.
In a world where digital transactions continue to reshape the landscape of commerce, PayPal (NASDAQ:) Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ:PYPL) stands out as a titan of the industry. The company, known for its robust technology platform enabling digital and mobile payments, has recently been the subject of an analysis by BTIG, LLC, which has downgraded the company’s stock from “Buy” to “Neutral.” This article seeks to consolidate the various perspectives and present a comprehensive picture of PayPal’s standing in the market.
Company Overview
PayPal’s global reach and its pivotal role in facilitating online payments for consumers and merchants have been well-established. The company now boasts over 430 million active customers and operates in more than 200 markets, having expanded its user base since the last report. Its two-sided network model continues to provide a fertile ground for increasing average revenue per user (ARPU) through the introduction of new products and services.
Market Performance and Trends
The digital payments sector is witnessing a resilient growth in US eCommerce, which bodes well for PayPal’s revenue prospects. However, BTIG has expressed concerns over persistent profitability pressures due to a shift in the company’s volume mix from branded to unbranded transactions, particularly the growth of lower-margin Braintree volumes. This shift is expected to continue impacting operating margins and has led to a reduction in operating margin expansion guidance for 2023. The firm anticipates a ~190bps decline in transaction margins during FY24 before stabilizing in FY25.
PayPal’s stock has been a subject of debate, with its P/E multiple currently around 10.7x, which is low compared to its historical average. The recent stock price of $58.45 is indicative of the balanced risks and structural profitability headwinds faced by the company.
Management and Strategy
Under the leadership of CEO Alex Chriss, PayPal is undergoing a strategic shift. The company is committed to cutting non-transaction expenses while focusing on running the company as a growth entity with potential for margin-accretive revenue growth and greater operational efficiency. PayPal is transforming into a platform-centric business, consolidating and monetizing data assets, particularly around checkout processes, and fostering small and medium-sized business development.
Despite the downgrade by BTIG, there are cost-saving opportunities that could drive EPS growth, but transaction margin dollar growth is currently more critical. Management expects negative transaction margin dollar growth for 4Q23 but anticipates a cleaner picture for FY24, with further cost savings beyond the identified ~$1.9bn for FY23.
Financial Metrics and Projections
Analysts have provided varying EPS estimates for PayPal, reflecting a general expectation of growth. Revenue growth is expected to be ~7.5% in FY23 and ~8.5% in FY24. Adjusted EPS is projected to grow ~21% in FY23 and ~10% during FY24. Potential catalysts include M&A announcements, acceleration in e-commerce, an accelerated buyback plan, or large partnership wins. In an upside scenario, there could be a 100bps margin expansion year-over-year, Venmo could resume pre-pandemic growth rates, and transaction margins could stabilize.
Competitive Landscape
In the fiercely competitive payments industry, PayPal continues to hold its own. The company is gaining market share in e-commerce volumes with sustained user frequency by active accounts. It is also expected to experience margin expansion through ongoing cost discipline. The introduction of higher-margin services like Risk-as-a-Service and FX-as-a-Service, along with international expansion and a move to cater to SMBs, are part of the broader strategy to maintain a competitive edge, despite the current margin pressures from Braintree’s growth.
Regulatory and External Factors
There is skepticism around using customer purchase data for promotional activities due to potential regulatory scrutiny and conflicts of interest. Moreover, the company’s approach to expanding financing services is under question, with some analysts preferring partnerships over in-house development to mitigate risks. Adverse currency movements and funding costs could impact EPS more than expected.
Bear Case
Is PayPal’s growth sustainable amid market shifts?
Some investors are concerned about PayPal’s ability to sustain growth, especially as it faces a shift towards unbranded volumes that could dilute transaction margins. The need for substantial investments to improve fundamentals and adapt to market changes could lead to downward EPS revisions. Additionally, the recent change in CEO and strategic direction adds a layer of uncertainty regarding medium-term financial expectations. Braintree’s continued growth at ~32% FXN could further pressure margins, and a significant slowdown in e-commerce during an economic downturn could negatively affect the company.
Can PayPal overcome margin pressures?
Despite efforts to offset margin pressures, such as the scale of PPCP and cost-saving initiatives, there is a bearish sentiment around the immediate future. The adjustment phase under new management may not yield significant changes in the short term, and there is a need for greater clarity on enterprise pricing and the new management’s plans.
Bull Case
Will new leadership propel PayPal forward?
The arrival of CEO Alex Chriss has been met with optimism. His focus on aligning resources to high-growth areas and a commitment to increased transparency could revitalize PayPal’s growth trajectory and efficiency. The consolidation of data assets and a strategy to boost small business adoption of PayPal’s payment solutions are seen as potential catalysts for improvement.
Is PayPal’s valuation an opportunity for investors?
Some analysts view PayPal’s current valuation as historically attractive, presenting an opportunity for investors. The company’s efforts to accelerate the growth of Branded TPV, which contributes the highest margins, and the introduction of new, higher-margin services could lead to a rebound in the stock’s performance.
SWOT Analysis
Strengths:
– Strong brand recognition and global scale.
– Diversified revenue streams with a growing unbranded volume.
– Strategic focus on high-margin services and international expansion.
Weaknesses:
– Dilution of transaction margins with the growth of unbranded volumes and Braintree.
– Need for substantial investment to improve fundamentals.
– Regulatory uncertainties around data usage for promotional activities.
Opportunities:
– Expansion into SMB markets and international territories.
– Potential for operational leverage through cost-saving initiatives.
– Leveraging data assets to improve consumer and merchant experiences.
Threats:
– Competitive pressure in the digital payments industry.
– Risks associated with foreign exchange fluctuations and funding costs.
– Execution risks related to new product launches and strategic shifts.
Analysts Targets
– Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC: Overweight; $118.00 (November 02, 2023).
– J.P. Morgan Securities LLC: Overweight; $80.00 (November 02, 2023).
– RBC Capital Markets: Outperform; $70.00 (November 02, 2023).
– BMO Capital Markets Corp.: Outperform; $90.00 (November 03, 2023).
– Barclays Capital Inc.: Overweight; $88.00 (October 12, 2023).
– Oppenheimer & Co. Inc.: Perform; No specific target (January 04, 2024).
– BTIG, LLC: Neutral; No specific target (January 05, 2024).
The timeframe for this analysis spans from September 2023 to January 2024.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.
Read the full article here